When being included doesn't mean you belong
When I was last asked to speak at a conference about inclusion and seafarers' wellbeing, I panicked. I wanted to say no. I don't see myself as an expert on inclusion at all. But then I thought, I do know what it feels like to be excluded. So let's start with that.
The alien on the wrong planet
Have you ever been included in something and still felt like an outsider? I have. Looking back, I realise that some of the moments when I felt most excluded weren't necessarily caused by people who wanted to leave me out. Sometimes, people were trying to do exactly the opposite. They wanted to include me, but they didn't always understand what that meant for someone like me.
As a woman working at sea, I was outspoken, spirited and certainly no wallflower. If I felt misunderstood or treated unfairly, I was quite capable of defending myself fiercely! But being able to stand up for yourself isn't the same as feeling comfortable in your surroundings.
It wasn't that people didn't try to let me in. Back then, it was completely normal to drink on a merchant vessel. After the watch, before dinner, all the officers and engineers gathered in the bar. The talk was mostly about women. I'll spare you the details. The drinks flowed, the laughter went on, and now and then someone asked me why I wasn't laughing. I sat there with my Coke and told them I didn't think it was funny.
Simply including me as one of their own obviously didn't work. I felt like an alien who had crash-landed on the wrong planet, both on board and ashore.
So, pulling someone into the mainstream hang-out sessions isn't necessarily what inclusion means, however well-meant the invitation. But what does it mean, then?
The cadet who went to his cabin
Not long ago, a captain came to me. He was struggling with a young trainee cadet who kept withdrawing to his cabin. The captain had asked him to come to the messroom for a beer after a long day. The cadet did, dutifully, but you could see he wasn't at home. He was upbeat enough at work and wasn't shy. The captain wanted to know how he could do his duty as a leader and include this young man more.
I told him how it would have felt to me. I would have felt awkward being pressured to join a work culture where I couldn't be fully myself. When I tried being myself, I was met with mockery and laughter. So I learned to hold back parts of myself, or pretend to be someone I wasn't.
Questions like "Would you like to join us?" or "Is everything OK?" might sound considerate, but they don't necessarily solve the problem. When the person asking is your superior, it's not easy to be honest. The cadet might simply say everything is fine, even when it isn't.
So we turned the question around. Instead of asking the cadet what's wrong with him or why he keeps withdrawing, the captain could acknowledge that perhaps they hadn't made him feel comfortable or welcome.
He could say something like: "We've noticed you tend to withdraw to your cabin after work, and we're wondering whether we've done something to make you feel uncomfortable. If we have, we'd really like to understand. Is there anything we could do differently?"
Now the responsibility isn't placed entirely on the cadet. The captain shows that he's willing to reflect on his own behaviour and that of the team, rather than expecting the young man to adapt to them.
Of course, the cadet might still say everything is fine. Trust takes time, especially when there's a hierarchy involved. The important thing is that the captain shows, through his actions as well as his words, that honest feedback is welcome and won't be held against him. Sometimes, inclusion starts with accepting that we might be part of the problem, even when we have the best intentions. And being willing to listen to an answer we might not expect.
Culture, character and hierarchy
Inclusion is more nuanced than telling someone to join your group. Culture, age, gender, religion, personality, whether you're an introvert or an extrovert, and your personal history all play a part.
Once, I sailed as chief officer on a small multi-purpose ship for three months. I was the only other officer besides the captain, and we had three crew members: a cook/bosun and two deckhands from the Philippines.
The ship had no separate mess room, so they ate with us at our table and cooked Dutch meals for us. Mash with endive and smoked sausage, a proper Dutch winter dish. Only, they'd forgotten to wash the vegetables, and we were all chewing sand! The captain said something to the cook about it. The cook looked visibly embarrassed. But he laughed, smiled and said, "Yes, yes."
I felt for him. I wondered how comfortable he could feel in that situation. They ate with us because there was no separate mess room, but I couldn't help wondering whether they would have preferred to eat separately and simply be themselves.
Two things were going on here: culture and hierarchy.
You can mean well and still not realise that people might struggle to relax when the boss is sitting at the table commenting on the food they've prepared. A leader might feel that everyone is equal and that their position is simply a role. But someone from a culture where hierarchy is highly respected may never feel comfortable speaking up or contradicting them.
The same goes for age. As a junior, you know that one misstep could end up in your review at the main office. You might be invited to speak freely, but do you actually feel safe enough to do so?
Being invited to the table doesn't automatically mean you feel you belong there.
What happens when people stop speaking up?
Everyone needs to feel valued and needed. Valued for what they bring, whoever they are, whatever they believe, whether they're considered weird or not weird, speak another language, or simply see the world differently.
In my belief, and in my practice as a coach, this is the foundation of wellbeing on board.
When someone goes quiet or starts withdrawing, there could be several things going on. They may feel unvalued: They don't want to see me. I don't matter. They don't care about my voice or my opinion. Or they may be afraid of being judged, making a mistake or speaking up against someone with more authority.
Either way, it's worth paying attention. Not just for the safety of the ship, but for the person themselves. Long periods of isolation and feeling unable to be yourself can contribute to stress, anxiety, declining mental wellbeing and, over time, more serious health problems.
We can't choose who we meet on board. Just like ashore, we meet all kinds of people, and we know that beforehand. We won't always understand each other, and we certainly won't always agree. So stay curious. Someone seeing things differently from you doesn't automatically mean there's something wrong with either of you. And their behaviour isn't necessarily personal.
What can we do differently?
We don't need to agree on everything, become best friends or enjoy the same activities. But we can make an effort to understand each other and create an environment where people feel comfortable being themselves.
A few things I think can make a real difference:
Be curious as a sign of respect. Ask about someone's language, share a few words in each other's languages, or ask about their holidays, family and what they like doing at home. Show an interest in the person, even if they don't want to join in with activities on board.
Don't force people to think or be the same. We can celebrate what we have in common without pretending our differences don't exist.
If someone goes quiet, check in with them. Don't jump to conclusions or assume they're unfriendly, disengaged or simply not interested. Ask how they're doing, and give them room to answer honestly.
Watch for signs of bullying and exclusion. Many of us don't speak up when someone is being treated badly because we're afraid of becoming the next outsider. That's understandable, but it doesn't mean we have to stay silent altogether. Even afterwards, you can tell the person that you didn't agree with the comment and that they can talk to you if they want to. Don't let them suffer in silence.
And remember that a friendly invitation is only the beginning. What matters is how people feel when they accept it, and whether they can be themselves once they're there.
The eye-roll I never forgot
As a trainee in the engine room, I had a hard time with the chief engineer. To me, he was ancient, scary, and always angry:) I was terrified of him and felt I didn't know enough, which was probably true. I was too scared to ask him anything.
When I made mistakes, he got so angry that he sent me out on deck and told me I was never welcome in the engine room again because I was so stupid.
I stood on deck trembling with anger and upset, shaking like a leaf. I would never in a million years have told my mentor or the captain. I knew they were on his side. Then a fellow junior officer came over. He saw I was upset and close to tears, stood in front of me and asked what was wrong. I told him the story.
He didn't say anything particularly significant. He rolled his eyes and made a noise that said, Gosh, that's not done. What an arse.
He didn't actually say that. But feeling heard and understood was enough for me, right then, to let it go. I knew it wasn't just my behaviour that was the problem. The chief engineer's behaviour was wrong too.
Moments like that shaped me. I still remember it today. A small act of kindness, with a huge impact. And there is the lesson. We don't always need to fix anything. We don't always need to confront the situation on the spot. Often it is enough to acknowledge someone's feelings and upset.
And sometimes, that's exactly what someone needs.
Inclusion is about more than an invitation
Noticing someone who feels excluded. Does that matter? Yes, it does. Especially when we're surrounded by people who are different from us, whether that's because of culture, gender, age, personality or simply the way we see the world.
We might not always get it right. We might even think we're doing the right thing and discover that we've missed the point entirely. That's where curiosity, kindness and a willingness to listen come in.
For me, inclusion isn't about making everyone fit in. It's about creating an environment where people don't have to pretend to be someone else to feel that they belong. And sometimes, it starts with something as small as an eye-roll from a fellow junior officer who lets you know you're not alone.